Skip to content
Monday, November 9, 2026
AlphaThoughts

Why Caicedo Was Sent Off While Bentancur Escaped: A Tale of Perceived Inconsistency.

Ten-man Chelsea secure Arsenal to a draw in fiery London derby.

Chelsea boss Maresca was left frustrated. Not because of the dismissal of his midfielder against Arsenal, but over what he viewed as a notable absence of consistency from the match referees.

It's easy to understand his perspective. Last month, Spurs player Rodrigo Bentancur was shown a yellow card for a challenge on Chelsea's captain, a ruling the video assistant referee (VAR) upheld. Yet, when the Ecuadorian was cautioned for a seemingly similar challenge on Mikel Merino, the official in the booth stepped in to recommend a red card.

"That is a sending-off offence, however, why was the Uruguayan's against Reece James not a red card? So us, as a manager, we struggle to understand why they judge in a different way," Maresca stated.

Analyzing the Difference?

Ultimately, rulings are often influenced upon the specific official on VAR duty—a factor that renders true consistency very difficult.

No two fouls is unique, and there were nuanced distinctions between the two challenges. Bentancur was primarily making a standing challenge, while the Chelsea man left the ground slightly and his impact was a bit more elevated.

There was also a pronounced buckle of Merino's ankle, a sign a VAR is looking for to indicate undue severity, and his foot was displaced on the turf.

In Bentancur's case, the Premier League's Key Match Incidents (KMI) Panel supported the yellow card for Bentancur by a vote of four to one, and agreed without dissent no VAR intervention "due to the reasoning that the tackle was low, marginally tardy and reckless".

This same panel will undoubtedly back the decision to dismiss the Chelsea midfielder, but it may not be long before a similar challenge of its type is judged only a booking.

Did the VAR Instruct the On-Field Official to Issue a Yellow Card?

The Chelsea midfielder will be banned for three games after his red card against the North London side.

Events on the field seemed a little confusing initially. Was referee Anthony Taylor being advised to book Caicedo so the foul could be checked?

There is a far simpler explanation.

Taylor allowed play to continue for the attacking team as the loose ball was with Eberechi Eze. Once the ball left play for a throw-in, the official returned to book Caicedo, who was receiving treatment. Referees are instructed to wait until an offending player is back on their feet before displaying a card.

Therefore, the pause was not because the VAR was checking; it was because the player was with the physio.

Video assistant referee Brooks can reach the determination that there was necessary force for a red, but he has to wait for Taylor to indicate his on-field ruling. The moment he brandished a caution, the video official immediately sent him to the review screen because the check had been completed during the treatment.

Referee Overturns Sending-Off Review

Also on Sunday, for just the second instance in the Premier League, a match official overturned a red card review at the pitchside monitor.

The referee did not award a free-kick against Jhon Arias, so in contrast to the Arsenal incident, the restart was a set piece to Aston Villa. The VAR, Bell, felt that the manner the player launched himself with both feet endangered Boubacar Kamara's safety.

However, the challenger was in the air and took a risk, making contact with the upper part of Kamara's boot. It lacked the level of intensity typically required for a straight red, although it was not a great challenge.

Should The Blues' Opening Goal to Be Ruled Out for an Offside Offence?

The VAR decided that the Argentine had no impact on the Arsenal backline when Chalobah headed in the first goal for the home side.

Once again, and another set of debatable offside decisions.

A possible offside on the Blues' opener appears to have escaped significant scrutiny.

The Chelsea captain floated a set-piece in from the left flank, and Chalobah flicked a header into the net.

But there was a potential issue. Fernandez was stood in an offside position and was very close to Arsenal's Hincapie and Cristhian Mosquera.

Was the midfielder influence the decision-making of the defenders? Had the Chelsea midfielder not been there, would there have been a better chance of preventing the goal?

Fernandez did not try to play the ball, and although he was not directly engaging with one defender, he had his arm on the other's shoulder.

You can make a very strong case for offside, so it comes back to a issue of uniform interpretation once again.

Should Hincapie Deserve Red for an Elbow?

Piero Hincapie started for Arsenal with their first-choice defenders ruled out through fitness issues.

The incident occurred moments after the Caicedo red card. The Arsenal defender jumped for a ball with the Chelsea player, and the Chelsea defender sustained contact through an impact by the arm on his face.

"I questioned the official, he said to me that it was not an elbow," Maresca explained. "So, this is what they said. He had a facial injury, with ice at the interval. But they decide in a different way."

Referees are advised not to make judgements based on a potential injury, though it occurs sometimes. A player can sustain a gash or a bruise from many kinds of contact, so it would not be logical.

Similar to dangerous tackles, officials have a set of criteria they assess for a possible elbow.

  • Was it an abnormal movement of challenging for a high ball?
  • Was there a closed fist, which indicates aggression?
  • Did the arm swung or lifted to create force?

None of these applied, so a yellow card was considered sufficient.

About the author

Joseph Mitchell

Tech journalist and futurist exploring AI ethics and digital transformation across industries.

AlphaThoughts

Type to search articles.